Does the City Belong to You?

The question that one must ask oneself (and to us) at this juncture is that, who then, does the city belong to? Whose history (or histories) are correct? We may not be able to answer the latter in the same binary form it is put forward, for history is neither black or white: it is mostly gray, although, the methods of reaching this gray area can be clearly classified as black and white. This is precisely why the unsubstantiated idea of equating Delhi with Indraprastha is at best fictional, since it does not have much basis in actual research-based historiography. As prominent historian Romila Thapar states, it is important for historians of the ancient period to look for assumptions that the epic makes about the past and the society, instead of  looking for historicity in a particular tradition–historians must look for such details instead of treating it as a factual account of events. 

The Mosque of Mubarak Begum

When The East India Company arrived in India, it made it compulsory for army men and British officials to either bring their wives along or marry a native. The British also adopted the Mughal practice of taking concubines or prostitutes as partners, which, however, became a problematic practice in the early years of the 19th … Continue reading The Mosque of Mubarak Begum

Coffee, Community, & Camaraderie

People who follow Bollywood closely may not remember that exactly a decade ago in 2010, Ashutosh Gowariker, the director of Lagaan which was India’s official entry to the Oscars, made another history-based movie called Khelein Hum Jee Jaan Sey, a story based on the revolutionary uprising in Chittagong (now part of Bangladesh) from 1930-34. The … Continue reading Coffee, Community, & Camaraderie

The Impermanent Nature of the Human Edifice

Sir Sayyid Ahmad Khan was a judicial officer (munsif) under the East India Company and was transferred to Delhi in 1846, after the death of his brother Munsif Sayyid Muhammad Khan. During his time in Delhi, Sir Sayyid Ahmad Khan continued to work on a newspaper (Sayyid-ul-Akhbar) started by his brother, and at the same … Continue reading The Impermanent Nature of the Human Edifice